Intro to Human Rights

Good evening Pirates,

I have been selected as the thematic coordinator for the CEEP category of Human Rights in the Digital Era. I hope to facilitate a zoom meeting with all interested parties and registered volunteers in the upcoming days in which I would like to discuss a common strategy and your input.

My hope is to refine the already wonderful program for the upcoming EP elections and help do work that is truly revolutionary. Currently, my hope is to introduce the right to internet access within the PPEU program.

I look forward to collaborating with you.


Below is the text from the 2019 CEEP chapter on Human Righs in the Digital Era. Please feel free to use it as a starting point for the discussions.

Right to Self-determination

We consider the people’s right to self-determination as self-evident.

Right to Privacy

A right to privacy is about protecting the powerless from the abuse and mistreatment of the powerful. Pirates believe that all individuals should have a right to privacy in their own personal lives. Privacy includes the rights to discretion and the right to be anonymous. Anonymity does not relieve any person of responsibility for their actions.

Security in Freedom

The expansion of our civil rights and protection of our freedom is a primary motivation for Pirates.

The threat posed by unlawful and excessive surveillance measures, imposed on us by governments both foreign and domestic, whether in response to terrorism or other types of crime, is grave. There is an immediate need for action to redress the balance and restore our privacy.

Privacy and Mass Surveillance

Europeans have a proud history of fighting for their fundamental rights and the freedoms of their fellow citizens.

To preserve our rights and freedoms, and to ensure the effectiveness of law enforcement, Pirates demand that data collection and monitoring is limited to people who are suspected of committing or preparing a crime and requires judicial approval and oversight.

Adequate protection against crime is an important responsibility of the state. We must ensure this responsibility is fulfilled through an intelligent, rational and evidence-based security policy.

Pirates wish to abolish the practice of routine, automated and untargeted data collection, storage and matching. We reject the blanket and indiscriminate collection of communications data (data retention), traveling data (PNR) and biometric data. Pirates oppose the automated profiling of people to divide them into risk categories (“profiling”) at borders (entry/exit system).

Public spaces are full of cameras that monitor the movement of people and vehicles, track faces, and combine this information without considering the potential for the erosion of privacy. Evidence demonstrates that the presence of such systems has little effect on the rate of crime and that, at best, crime simply shifts to other spaces. Pirates support and would prioritize the movement of police personnel from monitoring duties, to patrolling the streets. Pirates are against individuals being required to identify themselves if they are not suspected of committing a crime, especially when they are exercising their rights to protest or assemble.

Pirates oppose the exchange of personal data with countries that lack effective protection of fundamental rights except in emergencies.

Stopping New Surveillance Plans

Pirates want to stop the erosion of civil rights, that has taken on dramatic proportions in recent history. To ensure our safety, we do not need new surveillance laws, existing laws are sufficient.

In particular, we reject:

  • The proposal to make fingerprinting of all identity card holders in the EU obligatory.

  • Attempts to allow providers to retain communications data indiscriminately for “security” purposes in the context of the proposed ePrivacy regulation.

  • The proposed creation of a centralized EU Identity Register including fingerprints and facial images (“interoperability”).

  • Unilateral cross-border law enforcement access to data bypassing mutual assistance channels (“e-evidence regulation”).

  • Screening travelers using lie detectors („iBorderCtrl“ project).

Systematic Evaluation of Existing Surveillance Powers and Moratorium

Pirates support well-reflected measures to keep us safe but intend to abolish harmful interferences in our fundamental rights. We, therefore, want the European Fundamental Rights Agency to systematically examine all current and future surveillance powers and programmes as to their effectiveness, cost, adverse side effects, alternatives and compatibility with our fundamental rights.

Pirates advocate a moratorium on any further interference with our human rights by the security agencies of the EU in the name of internal security until the systematic review of existing powers by the FRA is complete.

Security Research

Pirates support the funding of research through the EU, however, the frequent involvement of government agencies in surveillance and filtering operations like INDECT and CleanIT demonstrates a clear intention to use such technologies in a way which makes them publicly funded tools for dismantling civil rights. We, therefore, argue that the EU must not fund technologies that limit fundamental rights.

Protecting Our Privacy Online

The proposed e-Privacy regulation will update privacy rules for e-communications. We reject attempts to allow providers to retain communications data indiscriminately for “security” purposes. The collection or use of personal data for data trade, advertising or market or opinion research must be allowed only with the active and informed consent of the person concerned.

Additional Internet privacy legislation is needed to ensure that information society services can be used and paid for anonymously, and do not indiscriminately record our online activities. We intend to replace the surveillance economy with an anonymous micropayment economy.

The right to use encryption shall be guaranteed. Support for end-to-end encryption shall be made compulsory for manufacturers of telecommunications equipment. Transport encryption shall be made compulsory for telecommunications operators, especially operators of international cables. National and inter-EU communications shall no longer be routed via third countries to prevent foreign intelligence agencies from intercepting them.

Export Controls of Surveillance and Censorship Technology

We support export controls of surveillance and censorship technology. We will not support the proliferation, by means of export credit or other state guarantees, of European-made surveillance and censorship technology to authoritarian countries that do not respect the rule of law. We will fight to uphold the privacy of journalists, activists and citizens around the world, by supporting legislation that prevents oppressive regimes from acquiring such technology and services from any entity in the European Union.

Just a little proposal for specification: We consider the people’s right to responsible self empowerment and self-determination as self-evident

(not really praising whatever comes to mind - and also not only determining (sounds like making passive choices) but also acting)

And there is another thing that stands without explanation and isn’t obviously about human rights:

" We intend to replace the surveillance economy with an anonymous micropayment economy." Whatever it means here it probably belongs under economy (that doesn’t exist but could be created renaming finances

I know the term “surveillance capitalism” is that the same? And where can I read about the micropayment economy?

Speaking about alternative economies, I am a little surprised that pirates seldom mention the sharing economy on the internet, since that is what many of us have grown up with. The free exchange of value in the form of computer programs and apps, blogs and podcasts, sharing of information and cultural products of all kinds. With no money involved, or new forms of double programs or websites where you get a simpler version for free (as a way for the traditional market to adapt to the sharing economy.) The sharing economy is gaining ground also outside the net where people share stuff and capacities.

Thank you so much for all your input. I will have the draft version finished by the end of today. I agree that the current HR program is a bit chaotically put together and I will be cutting parts that would likely belong to other areas. Open Data has been added as a category.